FDIC Cert #28712 Active FDIC Insured Commercial Lending Specialization

First Federal Savings of Middletown

22 James St, Middletown, NY 10940

FDIC Health Score
8.5/10
Well Capitalized

Quarterly Call Report Metrics

Total Assets $188.0M
Total Deposits $112.3M
Profitability (ROA) 1.86%
Shareholder Return (ROE) 5.08%
Capital Cushion (Eq/Assets) 36.49%
Established 01/01/1888
Depositor Yield Benchmark · November 2026

Compare First Federal Savings of Middletown Against Top National Audited Rates

Traditional regional and branch banks often pay near the national average (0.45% APY) on standard savings. Compare your current rate against our top-rated FDIC-insured online accounts and verified cash bonuses:

Is First Federal Savings of Middletown Safe? Balance Sheet & Health Analysis

First Federal Savings of Middletown is a currently active commercial lending specialization banking institution headquartered in Middletown, New York. Established in 01/01/1888, this institution operates under federal and state regulatory supervision and is insured by the FDIC under Certificate #28712.

As a chartered depository institution, First Federal Savings of Middletown manages $188.0M in total assets and holds $112.3M in customer deposits across 1 domestic branch office. When evaluating the safety of First Federal Savings of Middletown, one of the most important regulatory indicators is its Capital Cushion (Equity-to-Assets Ratio). At 36.49%, this ratio measures how much unexpected loan or securities loss the bank can absorb from shareholder equity before depositors' funds or the FDIC insurance fund are exposed.

In terms of operational earnings, the bank's annualized Return on Assets (ROA) is 1.86%, while its Return on Equity (ROE) sits at 5.08%. These figures produce a strong composite Health Score of 8.5 out of 10, indicating a well-capitalized and profitably managed balance sheet.

Regulatory Record & Branch Liquidity

Clean Regulatory Record

Active FDIC Certificate #28712 with no current FDIC conservatorship flags reported in the latest Call Report cycle.

Deposit Density per Branch

$112.3M average deposits per office across 1 domestic location. Higher deposit density per branch typically indicates lower physical overhead relative to the bank's funding base.

Compare With Similar-Sized Banks in New York

View all New York banks →
Institution Headquarters Total Assets Eq / Assets ROA Health Score
First Federal Savings of Middletown (Current) Middletown, NY $188.0M 36.49% 1.86% 8.5/10
Savannah Bank National Association Savannah, NY $187.2M 7.49% 0.66% 7.7/10
Bank of Richmondville Cobleskill, NY $185.9M 10.07% 0.70% 8.2/10
The Putnam County National Bank of Carmel Carmel, NY $182.7M 25.37% 1.31% 8.5/10
Gouverneur Savings and Loan Association Gouverneur, NY $198.9M 16.10% 0.62% 7.0/10
Massena Savings and Loan Massena, NY $199.9M 15.19% 1.09% 9.2/10
The First National Bank of Dryden Dryden, NY $203.9M 11.85% 1.48% 10.0/10

Operations & Headquarters

Charter & Web Registry

Official Website: www.firstfederalmiddletown.com

FDIC Certificate #: 28712

Primary Specialization: Commercial Lending Specialization

Headquarters Address

22 James St

Middletown, New York 10940

Open in Google Maps →

Frequently Asked Questions About First Federal Savings of Middletown

Is First Federal Savings of Middletown FDIC insured?

Yes. First Federal Savings of Middletown is an active FDIC-insured chartered bank operating under FDIC Certificate #28712, headquartered in Middletown, New York. Deposits are insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, for each account ownership category.

Is First Federal Savings of Middletown safe and financially healthy in 2026?

Based on the latest FDIC Call Report filings, First Federal Savings of Middletown earns a composite Health Score of 8.5 out of 10. It holds $188.0M in total assets, $112.3M in total deposits, an Equity-to-Assets capital cushion of 36.49%, and a Return on Assets (ROA) of 1.86%.

Who owns First Federal Savings of Middletown?

First Federal Savings of Middletown operates as an independent chartered institution headquartered in Middletown, New York, without a separate parent bank holding company reported in the current registry.

Where is First Federal Savings of Middletown headquartered and how many branches does it have?

First Federal Savings of Middletown is headquartered at 22 James St, Middletown, NY 10940, and was established on 01/01/1888. The institution reports 1 domestic office location with an average of $112.3M in deposits per branch.

Headquarters Map